News >> Browse Articles >> K-12 News

-5

Warning: Your Average Student Won’t Make it Here

Warning: Your Average Student Won’t Make it Here

Joanne Jacobs

“John Dewey,” who’s training to be a math teacher, thinks his child’s high-scoring suburban high school shouldn’t count out average students. The new principal sent a letter to parents that suggests that smart, motivated, mid-bell-curve students will flop.

The “Middle Child” is the type of student who does not feel at home at Langley because, while they may be smart and academically focused, they are not academically superior like many of their peers. Nor are they outstanding in extracurricular activities. This student does not enjoy the prospect of coming to school to face the intense competition, which is ubiquitous in excellent schools, only to be disappointed.

The principal hopes for dialogue on what to do about these non-outstanding students.

Dewey wants to hear: “Every child matters; every child is as important as the next.” He wants to see “a culture in which students who aren’t getting the material are identified and the school works with them after school or in special sessions to make sure they understand.”

It’s a little frightening to hear that there’s no place for B students at a large public high school. What about C students? What about the not-so-smart, not-so-motivated students?

From the Editor

How do you feel about this article? Let us know your thoughts on the philosophy of this school by commenting below.


-5
  • Scholar2_max50

    mrslater13

    2 months ago

    56 comments

    While there may be some value to grouping students by ability rather than simply by age, but this principal's attitude is condescending and exclusive. Grades in school reflect a student's ability to navigate the social environment of school as well as their knowledge of the subject material. The principal's approach really sounds lazy at heart, build a school filled only with students who have fully bought into school culture and systematically exclude students who might question the value of what the school has to offer. One has to wonder if the real motivation is to set up a school for academic excellence or if they want a school that will be easy and pleasant to teach at.

  • Dscn0557_max50

    sanmccarron

    2 months ago

    1078 comments

    Julia, perhaps you can post the accurate wording of the principal's message?

  • 1-9-2007-17_max50

    Julia

    2 months ago

    46 comments

    I teach at Langley. This article is absolutely not an accurate representation of what our principal wrote and what he and all of us who teach there are trying to do. At all schools there are those lost students, the invisible ones, who don't cause trouble, but who don't reach academic success for whatever reasons. Many of us who choose to teach were those children. The staff at this school is actively confronting this issue. We are aware that it is all too easy for some students to be left out and to not reach the success that we want for them unless we intervene. What a shame that the people who wrote this did not publish all of the compassionate message by our principal. If they had, then we would be talking about how important it is for all teachers to do what we at Langley are striving to do. There are many ways to benignly overlook students who don't really succeed, but who don't make waves. The staff at Langley chooses to not allow those "good kids" fall through the cracks.

  • Dscn0557_max50

    sanmccarron

    2 months ago

    1078 comments

    Is this a fictitious story or is there a real school behind it? I'd be shocked if a real school had the nerve to send out such an arrogant letter. If this story is true, parents should be outraged.

  • Smile_for_u_max50

    SBonilla07

    2 months ago

    574 comments

    Every child is still doing good in school as long as it's an A-C. So, why are they just wanting A+ students. Every child is different. Some are brilliant. Some need more time to absorb.

What's the Scoop?

Post a link to something interesting from another site, or submit your own original writing for the TheApple community to read.

Report News Here

Recent Activity

Photo_54_max30
Deven posted in: "Going, going, going...down!", 5 minutes ago.
Img000091_max30
ksteffen87 received the quiz result of "Excellent", 11 minutes ago.
P1010024
taternutz posted in: "Evolution or Intelligent Design?", 12 minutes ago.
P1010024
taternutz posted in: "The Great American Bailout", 17 minutes ago.
Photo_54_max30
Deven submitted the article: "Studies link part-time college faculty to worse education", 18 minutes ago.
Photo_54_max30
Deven submitted the article: "High school student assists in surgery", 20 minutes ago.
Photo_54_max30
Deven submitted the article: "Taking on the business world — from high school", 22 minutes ago.
Photo_user_blank_big
wadevanbrussel commented on: "A Plan for Teachers to Earn Over $100K", 23 minutes ago.
Photo_54_max30
Deven submitted the article: "Parents held accountable", 23 minutes ago.