Obama Unveils Plans for Education Reform
Democratic presidential candidate Barack Obama, the senator from Illinois, has unveiled his education agenda. Here, Obama is seen speaking at a town hall meeting in Flint, Mich., on Monday.
Associated Press
WASHINGTON (AP) — Barack Obama promised Tuesday to double funding for charter schools, pay teachers based on performance and replace those who aren’t up to the job, embracing education proposals normally more popular with Republican candidates.
The Democratic presidential nominee says both parties must work together to improve education in a pitch to independent voters in this presidential election swing state, where the fight over education reform has been the focus of a longtime partisan battle. It was the first of two days that Obama was spending on education policy.
Days after Republican candidate John McCain talked up the idea of school choice at the GOP convention, Obama proposed to give parents more options, too — but not with a federal voucher program to pay for private schools, something McCain has supported. Instead, Obama seeks to create an array of new public schools.
Despite McCain’s rhetoric, he is not proposing a federal voucher plan. Instead, he is proposing only to expand the voucher program in Washington, D.C.
The federal government spends about $200 million a year on charter schools, independently run institutions that receive public money. Obama’s proposal would take that up to over $400 million.
Obama recognized that charter schools have been a source of debate in Ohio. Past Republican administrations used charter schools and private school vouchers to offer families a way out of troubled public schools. But Democratic Gov. Ted Strickland has been trying to scale back voucher programs to focus taxpayer money on more traditional public schools.
The Ohio Federation of Teachers has complained about the management of some charter schools, which has moved money away from the schools where its members work. The union has asked the Internal Revenue Service to investigate for-profit charter school operator White Hat Management for allegedly violating the terms of the tax-free status assigned to some of its schools.
“I’ll work with all our nation’s governors to hold all our charter schools accountable,” Obama told an audience that included many educators and members of teachers unions. “Charter schools that are successful will get the support they need to grow. And charters that aren’t will get shut down. I want experimentation, but I also want accountability.”
While teachers unions typically oppose the idea of performance-based merit pay, Obama is embracing the idea along with demands that teachers who don’t meet standards are removed from the classroom. Obama’s campaign said teacher performance could be judged by peer review, student test results, classroom evaluations or other processes.
“One of the things we’ll have to do, and this is something that I know sometimes is difficult, is teachers who are doing a poor job, they’ve got to get extra support,” Obama said. “But if they don’t improve, then they have be replaced. Because as good teachers are the first to tell you, if we’re going to attract the best teachers to the profession, we can’t settle for schools filled with teachers that aren’t up to the job. That is something that we have to embrace.”
Obama also is proposing a new $500 million matching fund for technology in the classroom.
At the same time he called for an end to partisan bickering over education, Obama accused Republican rival John McCain of failing to do anything to improve the quality of public education during nearly three decades in Washington. “Not one real proposal or law or initiative. Nothing,” Obama said.
A new Obama television ad contends that the Arizona Republican voted to cut education funding and voted against accountability standards.
Later in the day, McCain’s campaign rolled out a fresh televison ad that says Obama’s only education accomplishment is “legislation to teach comprehensive sex education” to kindergartners.” The ad raises the question “learning about sex before learning to read?” and calls Obama “wrong for your family.”
Obama’s campaign called the ad “shameful and downright perverse.”
© 2008 YellowBrix, Inc.
lisap
6 days ago
4 comments
“Pen is mightier than sword.” Our great inheritance from our parents is their basic obligation to send us in school. Learning and acquiring more knowledge to be used in future employment career or even in normal daily life for us to get educated. The key ingredient to success is Education. As Americans emerge from the afterglow of the recent presidential election, while president-elect Barack Obama prepares to take the reins of the country, education is an issue that’s lingering on the minds of many. According to an article at The Apple, No Child Left Behind will be Obama’s first priority when it comes to education. He is not looking to snip the program, but he does intend to reform it, particularly when it comes to standardized testing. He does not support preparing students all year to “fill out bubbles.” Referencing schools, both Obama and vice president-elect Joe Biden support charter schools, as long as they perform up to standard. Teachers at charter schools and others are pleased with Obama's incentives like Teacher Service Scholarships and various pay rewards – this will certainly be a great help. Furthermore, part of the president-elect’s main concern is to boost Early Head Start programs and provide tax credit for college education. The course to repair faith in the American educational system through these ideas and more will definitely lead to the kind of credit repair the country needs. Click to learn more about Credit Repair.
MagPro85
8 days ago
8 comments
what might be a good idea is to implement what most foreign countries have already been doing. Okay here is how it goes: the teachers are submitted to a monthly inspections by their dept chair person, during each inspection the dept chairperson would sit in and observe their classroom. The following an interview asking the teacher a sample lesson plan on a thematic unit or so and providing a sample student work. The teachers are also to insure that the students do get the subject and can provide tutoring for the child when necssary. But then again in those foreign countries teachers are given better salaries (as much as any professional) and they are not looked down upon like in this country.
JoEllen
about 1 month ago
22 comments
I doubt if any presidential campaign before has addressed education. Only now is it seen as a national problem. I trust Obama will find the rght people to work out the problems with the NCLB laws and implementation. He knows he can't do it all by himself. We need a hotline for teachers to give support and suggestions. In CA, anything better would be almost anything!
MisterD
about 1 month ago
448 comments
NCLB Did not create a mess - people poorly implementing things created a mess. Whoever gets in there will be improvements (only) no one will scrap the basic intent which is good - even if poorly implemented by not well intentioned teacher/administrators.
Cindyx3
about 1 month ago
114 comments
I know something must change. I hope who ever gets in fixes the mess NCLB has created!
johnslat
about 1 month ago
1644 comments
Let's face it: there is NO ideal way of "measuring teaching performance." And yet, it is something that needs to be addressed. It's a fact that there are "teachers" out there who shouldn't be in the profession.
Perhaps a combination of assessments could be devised: peer reviews, test results, student/parent evaluations, even teacher testing (yes, I know teachers are supposedly proficient in their subject areas, but in my experience that simply isn't always the case.) Any other suggestions?
Deven
about 1 month ago
564 comments
Deborah, I see your point, and agree that any review should be meaningful. A "review," whether by a principal, an in-school peer or one from the outside, needs to be more than could be observed in a one-shot visit to a classroom.
One of the large problems of establishing peer reviews will be determining what aspects of a teachers job should be part of the review, how the review should be conducted, and what rubric should be applied. Like any kind of scientific measurement, a peer review should be able to be replicated by other reviewers who get the same, or very similar, results.
To address MisterD's comment, I agree. Peer reviews are too subjective. What we need are rigid comprehensive standards and uniform assessments to make sure those standards are being met.
MisterD
about 1 month ago
448 comments
Well johnslat, not that you know of anyway ;).
Interesting diversity of opinions on this one. I personally don't care for peer reviews but I do whatever I need to.
apple4blea
about 1 month ago
146 comments
Receiving a peer review from a teacher at another school seems unfair.
Coming into my classroom and getting a snapshot of what I do seems all a matter of perception. What should be meaningful, may turn into a pony show which I absolutely don't agree with.
johnslat
about 1 month ago
1644 comments
Dear MisterD,
Hmm, it doesn't a peer you have any takers on your generous offer yet. But I can't peer into the future.
Cindyx3
2 months ago
114 comments
I agree with Deven, it should be teachers from other schools.
MisterD
2 months ago
448 comments
I volunteer to be anyone here's peer!! Cindy , Sandra anyone .....
johnslat
2 months ago
1644 comments
My guess is that may well be Sandra's problem, too. The slackers always enjoy dragging the dedicated ones down - or trying to.
Deven
2 months ago
564 comments
The peer review should be by disinterested peers, perhaps those from a different school or district to avoid building-based politics and infighting.
johnslat
2 months ago
1644 comments
Dear Sandra,
Like Kansas, you have no peers.